지원사업
학술연구/단체지원/교육 등 연구자 활동을 지속하도록 DBpia가 지원하고 있어요.
커뮤니티
연구자들이 자신의 연구와 전문성을 널리 알리고, 새로운 협력의 기회를 만들 수 있는 네트워킹 공간이에요.
초록· 키워드
오류제보하기
This article, based on the sidenotes of the annals of Paekche Dynasty in the Samguk-sagi, examined the fonnative process of the sidenotes related 28 items and the editor's attitude toward the compiling of the Samguk-sagi. For this, I made the achievements of the examination on the sidenotes of the annals of Silla and Koguryo Dynasties done by myself before as the logical basis. The previous achievements were digested like the following: 1) each edition has different authors; 2) the authors give more trust to our traditional viewpoint than to Chinese materials; 3) most important, the editing of the Samguk-sagi did not rely upon a particular book. Eventually, it should be pay attention to the facts that the essential conclusions of a series of researches are strikingly similar each other.
However, in this subject I tried to place emphasis on the two different spheres. One was to speculate the existence of the original scurce of royal annals compiled prior to the Samguk-sagi It must be considered the broadest scurce for the composing the sidenotes of Samguk-sagithe other was to have comprehensive understanding of the author's attitude exposed in the middle of writings the sidenotes of annals of Paekche Dynasty. It will offer a profitable criterion to make a distinction among the original copies composed before the mid-Koryo dynasty. At the same time, the criterion could be regarded as a standard to presume the characters of editors.
Needless to say, broadly but crudely existing materials of Koryo dynasty were assembled to edit the Samguk-sagi. The editors neither have quantitative room to rule out important materials intentionally, nor any motive to distort them, nor necessity to hide such a motive. In addition, although domestic materials and Chinese information were recorded together, if contradicted each other, unique domestic materials were credited almost without exception. It means that the editors gave great dependence on the domestic materials including Samhan-kogi composed by the writers of Koryo dynasty or the Three Kingdoms,
Based on these results, one must continue to analyze the sources or process of compilation of the Samguk-sagi within the context of the material circumstances in and out of Koryo Dynasty. Of course those subjects should be treated as a foundation to ascertain the relation so-called Old Samguksa or Kogi, the general name of the previous historical documents in Koryo dynasty, But, now that the history of the Three Kingdoms rearranged by the people of Silla and the national history of Silla Dynasty written by its people served as the base for historical knowledge, there was no great difference in the nature of the history books compiled during the Koryo Period, either in the Old Samguksa or the Samkug-sagi.
However, in this subject I tried to place emphasis on the two different spheres. One was to speculate the existence of the original scurce of royal annals compiled prior to the Samguk-sagi It must be considered the broadest scurce for the composing the sidenotes of Samguk-sagithe other was to have comprehensive understanding of the author's attitude exposed in the middle of writings the sidenotes of annals of Paekche Dynasty. It will offer a profitable criterion to make a distinction among the original copies composed before the mid-Koryo dynasty. At the same time, the criterion could be regarded as a standard to presume the characters of editors.
Needless to say, broadly but crudely existing materials of Koryo dynasty were assembled to edit the Samguk-sagi. The editors neither have quantitative room to rule out important materials intentionally, nor any motive to distort them, nor necessity to hide such a motive. In addition, although domestic materials and Chinese information were recorded together, if contradicted each other, unique domestic materials were credited almost without exception. It means that the editors gave great dependence on the domestic materials including Samhan-kogi composed by the writers of Koryo dynasty or the Three Kingdoms,
Based on these results, one must continue to analyze the sources or process of compilation of the Samguk-sagi within the context of the material circumstances in and out of Koryo Dynasty. Of course those subjects should be treated as a foundation to ascertain the relation so-called Old Samguksa or Kogi, the general name of the previous historical documents in Koryo dynasty, But, now that the history of the Three Kingdoms rearranged by the people of Silla and the national history of Silla Dynasty written by its people served as the base for historical knowledge, there was no great difference in the nature of the history books compiled during the Koryo Period, either in the Old Samguksa or the Samkug-sagi.
목차
문제의 소재
Ⅰ.단순분주의 검토
Ⅱ.고증분주의 인식
향후의 과제
ABSTRACT
참고문헌 (0)
참고문헌 신청함께 읽어보면 좋을 논문
논문 유사도에 따라 DBpia 가 추천하는 논문입니다. 함께 보면 좋을 연관 논문을 확인해보세요!
-
『삼국사기』의 성격
한국학(구 정신문화연구)
2001 .03
-
A Study of the Records of Solar Eclipses in Samguk sagi (Ⅰ)
Korea Journal
1976 .07
-
A Study of the Records of solar Eclipses in Samguk sagi (Ⅱ)
Korea Journal
1976 .08
-
『삼국사기』 열전의 자료 계통
한국고대사연구
2006 .06
-
『삼국사기』와 『삼국유사』의 왕대력 비교 연구
한국사학보
2005 .11
-
An Introductory Study of the “Annals of Koguryŏ” in the Samguk Sagi
THE REVIEW OF KOREAN STUDIES
2012 .06
-
『삼국유사』의 사서적 성격
한국고대사연구
2005 .12
-
김부식의 생애와 업적
한국학(구 정신문화연구)
2001 .03
-
The Legends of Koguryŏ (Ⅰ) : Samguk sagi : Annals of Koguryŏ
Korea Journal
1982 .01
-
The Failure of Baekje’s Prudential Diplomacy : Revisiting the Samguk sagi from an International Relations Perspective
Korea Journal
2010 .06
-
The Annals of Silla of the Samguk Sagi
THE REVIEW OF KOREAN STUDIES
2013 .06
-
한국 유학의 흐름과 『삼국사기』
한국학(구 정신문화연구)
2001 .03
-
Chapter 41, 42, and 43 of the Samguk sagi: An Annotated Translation of Biography of Kim Yusin
THE REVIEW OF KOREAN STUDIES
2018 .06
-
Chapter 46 of the Samguk sagi: An Annotated Translation of Biographies of Gangsu and Others
THE REVIEW OF KOREAN STUDIES
2019 .12
-
『삼국사기』 천문 기록의 재검토: 중국 사서(史書) 의존성 기록을 중심으로
한국과학사학회지
2020 .01
-
Chapter 47 of the Samguk sagi: An Annotated Translation of Biographies of Haeron and Others
THE REVIEW OF KOREAN STUDIES
2020 .06
-
金富軾의 詩 世界
한국학(구 정신문화연구)
2001 .03
-
Chapters 44 and 45 of the Samguk sagi : An Annotated Translation of Biographies of Eulji Mundeok and Others
THE REVIEW OF KOREAN STUDIES
2018 .12
-
《삼국사기》 일식기록의 한중 사료 대조와 일식상황 비교
신라사학보
2016 .08
-
Koryo-sa : Complete History of the Koryo Dynasty
Korea Journal
1962 .03
이 논문의 저자 정보
이 논문과 함께 이용한 논문
최근 본 자료
댓글(0)
0