지원사업
학술연구/단체지원/교육 등 연구자 활동을 지속하도록 DBpia가 지원하고 있어요.
커뮤니티
연구자들이 자신의 연구와 전문성을 널리 알리고, 새로운 협력의 기회를 만들 수 있는 네트워킹 공간이에요.
논문 기본 정보
- 자료유형
- 학술저널
- 저자정보
- 저널정보
- 동양사학회 동양사학연구 東洋史學硏究 第155輯
- 발행연도
- 2021.6
- 수록면
- 361 - 404 (44page)
- DOI
- 10.17856/jahs.2021.6.155.361
이용수
초록· 키워드
오류제보하기
This article analyzes the processes, characteristics and realities of judicial reforms in Tianjin county(天津縣) during the New Policy Reform(新政) by focusing primarily on the new-type court, Tianjin Court(天津審判廳, TC). The reason why the TC was able to become China’s first “modern court” was that after the Tianjin sovereignty was transferred to the Qing dynasty in 1902, in order to reconstruct and strengthen the ruling system in Tianjin, Yuan Shikai(袁世凱), the Zhili Governor-General(直隷總督) attempted to reform the former judicial system, such as establishing the Tianjin County Judicial Bureau (天津縣發審局) and the Tianjin Police judicial bureau(南段巡警總局警讞局), which substitutingly handled the judicial function of the Tianjin magistrate.
As a new-type court, the TC took various unprecedented measures. First, in relation to the organization, the positions were subdivided according to the roles of personnel, and all the selections of personnel were conducted through examinations of legal and professional understanding. It also set up a detention house(拘留所) to detain unsentenced offenders, which traditionally did not exist. Second, regarding the litigation and trial system, new methods were introduced, such as the application of accusatory system (彈劾主義裁判), the principle of adjudication based on evidence (衆證主義) and the element of double jeopardy (一事不再理). The TC specified court costs according to the size of litigation not only to prevent personnel from corrupting but also to enable the involved to predict the cost.
In reality, however, existing judicial practices and perceptions still worked and constrained on these institutional reform. For example, the accusatory system could not be fully carried out due to the existing idea regard the lawyer as a litigant and the lack of understandings of the prosecution. In addition, the perception that only the confession was seen as complete evidence did not change. Furthermore, because of the public perception of proceeding and trials as a means of relieving their own regrets remained, the proceedings that ignored the formal regulation regarding trial and procedures frequently occurred, and the traditional method of settling the judgement depending on whether the parties accepted remained unchanged.
In short, the situation of the TC reveals the possibilities and limitations of the transitional times, in which a new system was being introduced to the traditional Chinese society.
As a new-type court, the TC took various unprecedented measures. First, in relation to the organization, the positions were subdivided according to the roles of personnel, and all the selections of personnel were conducted through examinations of legal and professional understanding. It also set up a detention house(拘留所) to detain unsentenced offenders, which traditionally did not exist. Second, regarding the litigation and trial system, new methods were introduced, such as the application of accusatory system (彈劾主義裁判), the principle of adjudication based on evidence (衆證主義) and the element of double jeopardy (一事不再理). The TC specified court costs according to the size of litigation not only to prevent personnel from corrupting but also to enable the involved to predict the cost.
In reality, however, existing judicial practices and perceptions still worked and constrained on these institutional reform. For example, the accusatory system could not be fully carried out due to the existing idea regard the lawyer as a litigant and the lack of understandings of the prosecution. In addition, the perception that only the confession was seen as complete evidence did not change. Furthermore, because of the public perception of proceeding and trials as a means of relieving their own regrets remained, the proceedings that ignored the formal regulation regarding trial and procedures frequently occurred, and the traditional method of settling the judgement depending on whether the parties accepted remained unchanged.
In short, the situation of the TC reveals the possibilities and limitations of the transitional times, in which a new system was being introduced to the traditional Chinese society.
목차
머리말
Ⅰ. 天津의 사법체제 재편과 審判廳 건설
Ⅱ. 새로운 재판 실험의 실상
맺음말
참고문헌
Abstract
참고문헌 (84)
참고문헌 신청
함께 읽어보면 좋을 논문
논문 유사도에 따라 DBpia 가 추천하는 논문입니다. 함께 보면 좋을 연관 논문을 확인해보세요!
-
韓国被爆者に対する市民団体の援護活動 - 孫振斗裁判を中心に -
대한일어일문학회 학술대회 발표논문 요지집
2019 .04
-
근세 조일 관계 속 쓰시마 번 裁判의 역할
동양사학회 학술대회 발표논문집
2023 .05
-
[토론문] “근세 조일 관계 속 쓰시마 번 裁判의 역할”에 대한 토론문
동양사학회 학술대회 발표논문집
2023 .05
-
도쿄재판이 전후 일본국민의 평화의식에 미친 영향
일본문화학보
2018 .02
-
판본의 異文을 통해 본 〈佛說大報父母恩重經〉의 문헌학적 특징?龍珠寺 판본을 중심으로?
한문학논집(漢文學論集)
2021 .01
-
언어유희로 읽는 주신구라(忠臣蔵)
아시아문화연구
2018 .12
-
唐代 지방 文書行政의 절차와 案卷의 재정리 - 『唐景龍3年(709)12月至景龍4年(710)正月西州高昌縣處分田畝案卷』의 검토를 중심으로 -
중국고중세사연구
2020 .05
-
조선후기 쓰시마 간사재판(幹事裁判)의 활동 검토
한일관계사연구
2018 .11
-
20세기 초 天津審判廳과 中·外 교섭재판
중국근현대사연구
2024 .06
-
韓国人被爆者に対する市民団体の支援活動 －日本の市民団体の活動とその意味－
일본문화학보
2023 .02
-
노다 히데키(野田秀樹)의 「판도라의 종」에 나타난 ‘천황의 전쟁 책임’에 관한 연구
일본문화학보
2016 .02
-
唐代 지방 政務의 처리 절차와 案卷 작성의 관계 ― 「唐開元二十一年(733)西州都督府案卷爲勘給過所事」의 분석을 중심으로 ―
중국고중세사연구
2021 .08
-
福島第一原発事故への責任＝応答可能性— 生業訴訟最高裁判決と東電株主代表訴訟東京地裁判決をめぐって —
일본학보
2022 .11
-
唐代 官文書의 작성과 地方 文書行政의 운영 - 敦煌·吐魯番 출토문서의 분석을 중심으로 -
동양사학연구
2019 .09
-
昌寧 仁陽寺 碑文의 判讀과 解釋
목간과문자
2019 .06
-
지각동사 “듣다”의 론항구조와 의미연구
중국조선어문
2015 .09
-
포항 중성리신라비 판독과 인명표기
목간과문자
2015 .12
-
Using Systemic Functional Linguistics and the Genre-Based Approach in EFL Classroom Language Communities of Practices
Journal of Asia TEFL
2023 .06
-
『대혜도경종요』에 있어서의 원효의 교판관 연구
불교철학
2018 .04
이 논문의 저자 정보
이 논문과 함께 이용한 논문
중서 문화 교류사 연구의 고전 ― 『중서교통사 1~5』 (방호 저, 손준식･유진희 역주, 학고방, 2019~2021) ―
李俊甲
동양사학연구
2021
.12
淸代 湖南西部 苗亂의 終熄
金弘吉
동양사학연구
2021
.12
元 仁宗 시기 토가치(脱火赤)의 반란과 킵착인 중쿠르(牀兀兒)의 정치 활동
여치호
동양사학연구
2021
.09
제국 안으로의 피신: 도적(Qulaɤan)과 몽골제국 권력
설배환
동양사학연구
2021
.09
중국의 국민국가 건설에서 혁명과 정치의 사이 - 이승휘 저 『손문의 혁명』 -
조병한
동양사학연구
2021
.03
최근 본 자료
댓글(0)
0
UCI(KEPA) : I410-ECN-0101-2021-910-001859940