메뉴 건너뛰기
Library Notice
Institutional Access
If you certify, you can access the articles for free.
Check out your institutions.
ex)Hankuk University, Nuri Motors
Log in Register Help KOR
Subject
Humanities
General Humanities History Philosophy Religious Studies Linguistics and Literature Other Humanities
Social science
General Social Science Business Management Tourism Education Military Science Library and Information Science Law Sociology Journalism and Media Studies Psychological Science Political Science and Diplomacy Geography Public Administration Economics International Trade Anthropology Other Social Science
Natural science
General Natural Science Physics Biology Life Sciences Mathematics/Statistics Astronomy Earth Science Chemistry Other Natural Science
Engineering
General Engineering Architectural Engineering Mechanical Engineering Industrial Engineering Material/Energy Engineering Electrical and Electronic Engineering Marine and Ocean Engineering Chemical Engineering Computer Science Other Engineering
Medical science
General Medical Science Nursing Science Veterinary Pharmacy Traditional Korean Medicine Basic Medicine Clinical Medicine Other Medicine
Agriculture and Fishery
General Agriculture and Fishery Agriculture Fishery Science Food Science Forestry Animal Husbandry Marine Transportation Studies Other Agriculture and Fishery
Art and Kinesiology
General Arts Design Fine Arts Cosmetology Photography Music Fashion Kinesiology Performing Media Arts Other Arts and Kinesiology
Interdisciplinary Studies
Interdisciplinary Research Science and Technology Studies Brain and Cognitive Science Technology Policy Other Interdisciplinary Studies

KOR

“Why Is There Anything Rather Than Nothing?”: A Critical Appraisal of Grünbaum's Critique on “Primordial Existential Question” and His Reading of Leibniz and Bergson
Recommendations
Search
Questions

“왜 아무 것도 없지 않고 어떤 것이 있는가?”: 원초적 실존의 문제에서 시원적 발생의 문제로

논문 기본 정보

Type
Academic journal
Author
Rhee, Jeesun (강원대)
Journal
The Society of Philosophical Studies Journal of The Society of philosophical studies Vol.132 KCI Accredited Journals
Published
2021.3
Pages
119 - 145 (27page)
DOI
10.23908/JSPS.2021.3.132.119

Usage

cover
📌
Topic
📖
Background
🔬
Method
🏆
Result
“Why Is There Anything Rather Than Nothing?”: A Critical Appraisal of Grünbaum's Critique on “Primordial Existential Question” and His Reading of Leibniz and Bergson
Ask AI
Recommendations
Search
Questions

Abstract· Keywords

Report Errors
Why is there anything rather than nothing? This question is one of the most fundamental problems of metaphysics, now approached by science, especially cosmology, but still regarded as ultimate so that its solution cannot be found in science (only). Contemporary cosmology finds herself channeged by theologians and philosophers of religion whose concern is to renew the classical cosmological argument to prove the existence of God. A. Grünbaum criticizes the challenge as well as the problem itself: he calls it “Primordial Existential Question (PEQ)” and qualifies a pseudo-problem. To him theological attempts leading from the PEQ to the cosmological analysis and looks into the history of philosophy: he refers to Leibnizian original version of PEQ in Principle of Grace and Nature and Bergson’s critique on it. This paper will first introduce the PEQ, then review Grünbaum’s analysis and his references to Leibniz and Bergson. Next, I present an alternative reading of PEQ based on Leibniz’s 1696 text “Ultimate Origin of Things” and Bergson’s lecture notes on it, then I turn to the “ideal genesis of matter” as discussed in Bergson’s Creative Evolution. This will show that the PEQ is not, as Grünbaum puts it, a “pseudo-problem,” but rather a “veritable problem” which would not simply go away with its effectiveness and productivity.
#그륀바움 #라이프니츠 #베르그손 #우주론 #우주생성론 #우주론적증명 #Grünbaum #Leibniz #Bergson #Cosmology #Cosmogony #Cosmological Argument

Contents

【요약문】
1. 들어가는 말: A. 그륀바움(1923-2018)
2. PEQ의 논리적 구조
3. 그륀바움의 PEQ 비판
4. 문제의 전환 : 실존에서 발생으로
5. 나오는 말: 존재에 대한 물음에서 생성에 대한 물음으로
참고문헌
〈Abstract〉

References (0)

Add References
If the reference is being serviced by DBpia, please register through [Add Reference]

Recommendations

It is an article recommended by DBpia according to the article similarity. Check out the related articles!

Related Authors

Frequently Viewed Together

왜 바보 세 사람이 모이면 문수보살의 지혜가 나오는가? : 창발 외
강준만 인물과사상 2016 .02
On the concept of Human rights in Habermas`s Legal and political theory
Ji Sun Lee Korean Journal of Legal Philosophy 2011 .08
The Dilemma of Supervenience-Based Physicalism
Woo Jin Han Journal of The Society of philosophical studies 2008 .03
특집2:근현대 민족현실과 지식인 전쟁세대의 좌절과 4월혁명세대의 두 가지 길
하일민 Critical Review of History 1992 .08
역사적 삶의 현장에서
하일민 철학과 현실 1996 .06

Recently viewed articles

Investigation of Preconditioning Effect for Cold Storage of ‘Cheongdobansi’ Non-astringent Persimmon
Jeong-Mi Kim, Ji-Young Kim, Il-Ho Kim 외 2명Korean Society For Horticultural Science2014.10
 The Structural Relationship among Leisure attitude, Leisure perception and Psychological happiness of middle-aged women participating in leisure sports
Yang, Won-Hee, Yeo 외 3명The Korean Society Of Sports Science2021.02
 한국교회의 선교현황과 문제점
권혁률Korean Association of Women Theologians2000.12

Comments(0)

0

Write first comments.

UCI(KEPA) : I410-ECN-0101-2021-100-001626661